05.06.2013 Views

RIVISTA DI DIRITTO TRIBUTARIO INTERNAZIONALE - Rdti.it

RIVISTA DI DIRITTO TRIBUTARIO INTERNAZIONALE - Rdti.it

RIVISTA DI DIRITTO TRIBUTARIO INTERNAZIONALE - Rdti.it

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

c Lollio: Some tllOUghts slzared on tlze ne't' provisiol1s on co-ordil1ated".<br />

in <strong>it</strong>s originaI version, provide for co-ordinated and continuous colla boration<br />

contracts (31).<br />

At first <strong>it</strong> was only w<strong>it</strong>hin the amb<strong>it</strong> of income tax legislation that the<br />

tax legislator became aware of incomes eamed by an "intermediate" category<br />

of \vorkers.<br />

Remembering the precedents set by emplovment case law, <strong>it</strong> assimilated<br />

co-ordinated and continuous collaboration contracts to free lance<br />

work contracts.<br />

The frequency w<strong>it</strong>h which, in practice, co-ordinated and continuous<br />

collaboration contracts were recognised ensured that article 49 or Presidential<br />

Decree no. 597 dated 29 September 1973 to be structured as an<br />

open provision: il contained, in fact, a list bv way or example (32) of the<br />

(31) The introduction of co-ordinated and continuous collaboration contracts into<br />

artide 5 of Presidential Decree no, 633/1972 took piace, pursuant to Presidential<br />

Decree no. 687 of 23 December 1974, by ùrtue of which the new version of artide 5<br />

provides that "services provided by natural persons who carry out as their ordinaI);<br />

business, albe<strong>it</strong> not in an exclusive rnanner, any free lance \\lork activ<strong>it</strong>y, w<strong>it</strong>h the exception<br />

of those activ<strong>it</strong>ies which regard co-ordinated and continuous work activ<strong>it</strong>ies<br />

proùded for at letter a) of artide 49 of Presidential Decree no, 597/1973 and which<br />

require the enrolrnent in boards, roles and professional lists are considercd services<br />

provided in the perlonnance of a trade or profession,<br />

The subsequent Presidenti al Dccree no. 24 dated 1979 thus modifies artide 5:<br />

" .... the provision of sen'ices relating to co-ordinated and continuous collaboration contracts<br />

provided for by article 49 of Presidential Decree no. 597, perforrned by persons<br />

who provide such services as their hab<strong>it</strong>ual profession, are not considered as hming<br />

been canied out in the perlonnance of a trade or profession".<br />

(32) Cfr. The code of conduct and the interpretation of the inst<strong>it</strong>ute of chartered<br />

accountants on incorne taxes, value added tax and related l<strong>it</strong>igation direct taxation and<br />

VAT, 1975, 26, which clarifies that apart from the types of contraci set out in letter a)<br />

of artide 49 of Presidenti al Decree no. 597/1973, the following typcs of incorne are also<br />

qualifiable as incorne arising out of co-ordinated and continuous collaboration contracts:<br />

l) incorne from senices provided by natural persons and partnerships pursuant<br />

to artide 5 of Presidential Decree no. 597/l973; 2) income from senices which have<br />

an employer; 3) incorne from seniccs \vhich have as their scope a continuous nonsubordinated<br />

contract, which is different from professional activ<strong>it</strong>y and from commerciai<br />

enterprises, or w<strong>it</strong>hout the latter if <strong>it</strong>s scope comes \v<strong>it</strong>hin thc ambi t of artide<br />

2195 of the Civil Code; 4) income from senrices which are nonnally performed at<br />

the prernises of an employer but w<strong>it</strong>hout any requirement of subordination; 5) income<br />

from services which are functionally placed w<strong>it</strong>hin the employer's acti\<strong>it</strong>ics; 6) income<br />

from senices are continuous, that is to sa)', w<strong>it</strong>h a contractual duration for a more or<br />

less long peri od, even if of an intenn<strong>it</strong>tent nature.<br />

Further evidence of the possibil<strong>it</strong>y of widening the list is contained in artide 49<br />

of ministerial circular no. l/RT dated 15.12.1973, in which the Tax Administration,<br />

although not getting involvcd in the interpretation of the exprcssion "and sundry",<br />

<strong>RIVISTA</strong> <strong>DI</strong> <strong>DI</strong>RIITO TRIBL'TARIO INTER.\AZIONALE 312001

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!