Musica che affronta il silenzio - Scritti su Toru Takemitsu - Pavia ...
Musica che affronta il silenzio - Scritti su Toru Takemitsu - Pavia ...
Musica che affronta il silenzio - Scritti su Toru Takemitsu - Pavia ...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Music Facing Up to S<strong>il</strong>ence. Writings on Tru Takemit<strong>su</strong><br />
In terms of religion, one only has to think of the insistence in all the schools of Zen Buddhism<br />
on the need to go beyond the words, whether written or spoken, to grasp experience in<br />
its nascent state, in all its ‘innocence’, before it is captured and imprisoned in the net of<br />
words, concepts and reasoning. For Westerners accustomed to the pre-eminence of the logos<br />
this is a particularly difficult concept. I dissent from those who insist on the distinction between<br />
a ‘mystical’ Orient and a ‘rational’ West. One can recognise an analogous quest for<br />
pure experience in the work, for example, of the outstanding ph<strong>il</strong>osopher Edmund Husserl: in<br />
essence all phenomenology is characterised by the attempt to arrive at a pure, pre-categorical<br />
experience, prior to the appearance of words, concepts and so forth.<br />
Let us look, for example, at two passages from Dgen:<br />
It means that the universe is not bound by ideas of vast or minute, large or small; it is not<br />
square or round, not the center, not liveliness, not brightness – when we transcend those<br />
forms the universe emerges. (Dgen 1975: 24) 3<br />
[Water] that is not bounded by any bank or shore: this is water that is clean right to the<br />
bottom. When fish move through this water, swimming is not non-existent. Swimming,<br />
for however many tens of thousands of distances it progresses, is unfathomable and is<br />
unlimited. There is no bank from which to <strong>su</strong>rvey it, there is no air to which it might <strong>su</strong>rface,<br />
and there is no bottom to which it might sink. Therefore, there is no one who can<br />
fathom it. If we want to discuss its mea<strong>su</strong>rements, [we say] only that the water is clean<br />
right to the bottom. (Dgen 1994: 104) 4<br />
This metaphor of water is one of the most common in Buddhist teachings. It is fundamental<br />
because it explains, better than any other abstract concept, that experience cannot be captured,<br />
and yet it is at the heart of every capture. In this sense there is no opposition, but continuity.<br />
Alternatively we can consider the sense of this outburst by Linji, a master of the<br />
Rinzai school:<br />
Students of today get nowhere because they base their understanding upon the acknowledgment<br />
of names. They inscribe the words of some dead old guy in a great big<br />
notebook, wrap it up in four or five squares of cloth, and won't let anyone look at it.<br />
‘This is the Mysterious Principle’, they aver, and safeguard it with care. That’s all<br />
wrong. Blind idiots! What kind of juice are you looking for in <strong>su</strong>ch dried-up bones!<br />
(Linji 2009: 260)<br />
The meaning is perfectly clear: truth, like water or nature or s<strong>il</strong>ence, cannot be grasped.<br />
Whoever seeks to follow the writings or teachings of some master or other is an idiot: Linji<br />
is that famous no-nonsense tea<strong>che</strong>r who said, ‘If you meet Buddha, k<strong>il</strong>l him’. If you should<br />
3 See also chs. 23 (T<strong>su</strong>ki), 24 (Gaby) and 61 (Rygin). Or. ed. Dgen Zenji, Shbgenz, Nakayama Shobo,<br />
Tokyo, 1975: 7, Ikkamyju [A shining pearl].<br />
4 Or. ed. Dgen Zenji, Shbgenz, Nakayama Shobo, Tokyo, 1975: 12, Zazenshin [Instructions for zazen].<br />
153