18.12.2012 Views

Proceedings

Proceedings

Proceedings

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Figure 2. Evolution of value relevance increment of CFS relative to PFS<br />

2003-2004 2005-2006 2007-2008 2003-2008<br />

Adj. R 2 Model 1 PFS 56.8% 64.9% 51.2% 53.2%<br />

Adj. R 2 Model 3 CFS* 65.6% 75.8% 77.0% 68.4%<br />

∆ Adj. R2 (M3-M1) 8.8% 10.9% 25.8% 15.2%<br />

Sig. 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000<br />

To continue, we tested regression model 4, developed to verify the hypothesis<br />

regarding the superiority for the capital market of information provided (together) by<br />

consolidated financial statements and parent company statements as opposed to<br />

consolidated information. The empirical results are synthesized in table 9.<br />

Table 9. Empirical results for regression model 4<br />

Period /<br />

Sample<br />

2003-08<br />

n= 548<br />

Alfa<br />

t<br />

VIF<br />

α0<br />

10.279<br />

9.093****<br />

-<br />

cBV<br />

0.692<br />

9.220****<br />

4.525<br />

Characteristics MODEL 4<br />

∆pBV cE ∆pE<br />

0.381 5.384 1.845<br />

4.049**** 10.640**** 3.862****<br />

2.75 5.916 3.247<br />

F Adj. R2<br />

282.185 68.60%<br />

2003<br />

n= 88<br />

Alfa<br />

t<br />

VIF<br />

9.266<br />

4.739****<br />

-<br />

0.58<br />

3.211****<br />

6.361<br />

0.211<br />

1.08<br />

2.628<br />

3.954<br />

3.023***<br />

4.631<br />

1.341<br />

1.455<br />

1.588<br />

36.676 65.50%<br />

2004<br />

n= 86<br />

Alfa<br />

t<br />

VIF<br />

10.02<br />

4.932****<br />

-<br />

0.57<br />

3.536***<br />

5.223<br />

0.284<br />

1.447<br />

2.715<br />

4.565<br />

3.533****<br />

8.844<br />

2.123<br />

1.526<br />

5.786<br />

43.689 67.80%<br />

2005<br />

n= 88<br />

Alfa<br />

t<br />

VIF<br />

12.334<br />

4.585****<br />

-<br />

1.042<br />

5.064****<br />

2.165<br />

0.444<br />

1.646*<br />

1.959<br />

4.946<br />

3.248***<br />

2.28<br />

3.688<br />

2.382**<br />

1.816<br />

54.156 71.40%<br />

2006<br />

n= 84<br />

Alfa<br />

t<br />

VIF<br />

14.847<br />

5.456****<br />

-<br />

1.039<br />

4.698****<br />

7.03<br />

0.422<br />

1.737*<br />

2.93<br />

4.298<br />

2.523**<br />

9.714<br />

-0.36<br />

-0.204<br />

4.457<br />

80.453 79.70%<br />

2007<br />

n= 87<br />

Alfa<br />

t<br />

VIF<br />

11.779<br />

3.948****<br />

-<br />

0.4<br />

2.042**<br />

5.211<br />

-0.51<br />

-0.196<br />

3.864<br />

7.403<br />

6.349****<br />

5.228<br />

2.702<br />

2.124**<br />

3.386<br />

64.171 75.10%<br />

2008<br />

n= 89<br />

Alfa<br />

t<br />

VIF<br />

8.933<br />

4.597****<br />

-<br />

0.346<br />

2.770***<br />

5.82<br />

0.289<br />

1.962*<br />

3.959<br />

4.036<br />

5.670****<br />

6.621<br />

-0.004<br />

-0.005<br />

5.279<br />

76.529 78.40%<br />

Frankfurt<br />

n= 192<br />

Alfa<br />

t<br />

VIF<br />

17.099<br />

6.411****<br />

-<br />

0.356<br />

2.207**<br />

4.504<br />

0.76<br />

0.382<br />

3.97<br />

5.347<br />

6.844****<br />

3.508<br />

1.287<br />

1.931*<br />

2.342<br />

48.063 50.80%<br />

London<br />

n= 174<br />

Alfa<br />

t<br />

VIF<br />

4.384<br />

7.464****<br />

-<br />

0.47<br />

2.175**<br />

3.145<br />

0.16<br />

0.667<br />

1.875<br />

5.275<br />

6.964****<br />

2.881<br />

0.992<br />

1.091<br />

2.099<br />

44.292 52.30%<br />

Paris<br />

n= 171<br />

Alfa<br />

t<br />

VIF<br />

23.66<br />

6.972****<br />

-<br />

0.385<br />

2.917***<br />

4.099<br />

0.117<br />

0.755<br />

2.983<br />

5.385<br />

6.165****<br />

10.7<br />

2.803<br />

3.481**<br />

7.699<br />

63.212 60.00%<br />

**** significant at 0.001; *** sig. at 0.01; ** sig. at 0.05; * sig. at 0.1<br />

~ 645 ~

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!