07.12.2012 Views

BODY AND PRACTICE IN KANT

BODY AND PRACTICE IN KANT

BODY AND PRACTICE IN KANT

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

4. THE <strong>BODY</strong> <strong>IN</strong> THE CRITIQUE<br />

The field of philosophy in this cosmopolitan<br />

meaning may be summed up in the following<br />

questions:<br />

l) What can I know?<br />

2) What ought I to do?<br />

3) What may I hope?<br />

4) What is man?<br />

The first question is answered by metaphysics, the<br />

second by morality, the third by religion, and the<br />

fourth by anthropology. At bottom all this could<br />

be reckoned to be anthropology, because the first<br />

three questions are related to the last.<br />

From Kant’s Logic 1<br />

In this passage Kant defines the task of what he calls a cosmopolitan<br />

[weltbürgerlichen] philosophy through four questions. What can I know?<br />

What ought I to do? What may I hope? What is man? These questions<br />

are said to define metaphysics, ethics, religion and anthropology.<br />

However, the last question stands in a particular position relative to the<br />

others, he claims, because it is more basic than all the rest. Before we can<br />

answer the others, we have to know what man is.<br />

In this second part, I will look at passages from the Critique. More<br />

than any other of his texts, this work relates to the first of the four<br />

questions: ‘What can I know?’ But Kant says that answering this question<br />

presupposes a thorough reflection upon the anthropological question of<br />

what a human being is. The passage also suggests that Kant based his<br />

epistemological enquiries on such reflections, i.e. reflections in the field of<br />

anthropology. Is that really so? And what happens if we take this idea of<br />

the primacy of anthropology seriously? How does it affect our<br />

interpretation of the Critique? In what follows I will attempt to give the<br />

beginning of an answer to this question. That is, my interpretation will be<br />

based on the assumption that Kant’s anthropology is part of the context<br />

1 Ak IX: 25

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!