SODBatch A&B SPM Comments co-chair response final ... - ipcc-wg3
SODBatch A&B SPM Comments co-chair response final ... - ipcc-wg3
SODBatch A&B SPM Comments co-chair response final ... - ipcc-wg3
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Chapter-<br />
Comment<br />
para<br />
Batch<br />
From Page<br />
From Line<br />
To Page<br />
To line<br />
<strong>Comments</strong><br />
IPCC WGIII Fourth Assessment Report, Se<strong>co</strong>nd Order Draft<br />
Expert Review of Se<strong>co</strong>nd-Order-Draft<br />
Confidential, Do Not Cite or Quote<br />
Response suggested by <strong>co</strong><strong>chair</strong>s<br />
<strong>SPM</strong>- 27 A 15 16 15 16<br />
use the term "tradable emission rights" throughout the entire report<br />
(Government of The Netherlands)<br />
does the quote "while the distribution of allowances" excludes the REJ; wording used does not<br />
1101<br />
option of auctioning? Maybe include the reference to (full)<br />
auctioning too, that may be needed to attain effectiveness of the<br />
instrument.<br />
(Aviel VERBRUGGEN, University of Antwerp)<br />
exclude auctioning<br />
<strong>SPM</strong>- 27 A 15 17 0 0 Replace "<strong>co</strong>mpetitiveness" with 'equity'. Competitiveness is only REJ; “<strong>co</strong>mpetitiveness” is<br />
1102<br />
one aspect of distrubutional issues.<br />
(Harald Winkler, University of Cape Town)<br />
clearer than “equity”<br />
<strong>SPM</strong>- 27 A 15 17 15 17 Add after the end of the sentence "If tradable permits are <strong>co</strong>mbined REJ; tradable permits are<br />
1103<br />
with an emission cap, high environmental certainty is provided<br />
about achieving the emission target".<br />
(Government of The Netherlands)<br />
always <strong>co</strong>mbined with a cap<br />
<strong>SPM</strong>- 27 A 15 18 0 21 It is possible that information campaigns and awareness raising TIA when reformulating; see<br />
1104<br />
may take some time to reach a tipping point on emission<br />
reductions; even if not directly effective, they may <strong>co</strong>nstitute<br />
crucial enabling <strong>co</strong>nditions for other measures such as policy<br />
interventions to be effective.<br />
(Stephen Sheppard, University of British Columbia)<br />
also A-1086, 1104-1113<br />
<strong>SPM</strong>- 27 A 15 18 15 19 The claim that voluntary measures are "politically attractive" is true TIA when reformulating; see<br />
1105<br />
not in general but particularly for businesses and others who wish<br />
to avoid <strong>co</strong>sts, but not for environmentalists and others who wish to<br />
reduce emissions.<br />
(Paul Baer, E<strong>co</strong>Equity)<br />
also A-1086, 1104-1113<br />
<strong>SPM</strong>- 27 A 15 16 15 16 The distribution of allowances has wealth (profitability)<br />
ACC; drop “e<strong>co</strong>nomic<br />
1106<br />
implications. It has implications for <strong>co</strong>mpetitiveness in an extended<br />
meaning (long term <strong>co</strong>mpetitiveness, which rests on profitability),<br />
though little implication for <strong>co</strong>mpetitiveness in a narrow sense (at<br />
the margin). It has little implication for e<strong>co</strong>nomic efficiency, if any,<br />
as the <strong>final</strong> location of emission reductions does not depend on the<br />
initial distribution of allowances.<br />
(Cédric PHILIBERT, International Energy Agency)<br />
efficiency”<br />
<strong>SPM</strong>- 27 A 15 18 15 21 Replace ' Voluntary agreements between industry and governments TIA when reformulating; see<br />
Action<br />
for<br />
chapter<br />
Considerations<br />
by the writing<br />
team<br />
Page 294 of 348
Change language