27 February 2007 - Ordinary Meeting of Council (pdf. 14MB)
27 February 2007 - Ordinary Meeting of Council (pdf. 14MB)
27 February 2007 - Ordinary Meeting of Council (pdf. 14MB)
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
No Date Lodged Appeal # Appellant Property Address Solicitor for<br />
Appellant<br />
Alterations & Additions<br />
14 Coronga<br />
1 April 15, 2005 10349/2005 David Johnson & MeCrescent Killara Maddocks DA0120/05<br />
49 Telegraph Road<br />
2 June 17, 2005 40607/2005 David McGovern & RPymble N/A DA1417/04<br />
3 Elgin Street<br />
3 December 5, 2005 11433/2005 Thomas Ho & CathyGordon<br />
1 Ray Street<br />
4 August 4, 2006 10683/2006 Charny Holdings PtyTurramurra<br />
5 September 15, 2006 10852/2006 Graeme Fisk<br />
Farmer<br />
Campbell<br />
Edmunds<br />
Herbert Geer &<br />
Rundle<br />
DA No Decision Appealed Against Solicitor Hearing Date Decision Date Result Staff Rec <strong>Council</strong><br />
Decision<br />
DA0937/05<br />
DA0581/06<br />
4 Allard Avenue<br />
Roseville McKees DA0446/06<br />
Deemed Refusal <strong>of</strong> additions and<br />
alterations to existing residence Abbot Tout July 5, 2005 August 5, 2005<br />
Class 4 Challenge to validity <strong>of</strong><br />
consent. (M Allan is second<br />
Respondent) Deacons 4,5,6 September 2006<br />
Refusal <strong>of</strong> demoliton <strong>of</strong> existing<br />
structures and construction <strong>of</strong> a new<br />
two-storey dwelling and pool<br />
Deacons<br />
Deemed refusal <strong>of</strong> additions and<br />
alterations to existing supermarket and<br />
construction <strong>of</strong> basement car parking. Deacons 13 & 14 November 2006 November 15, 2006<br />
Deemed refusal <strong>of</strong> additions and<br />
alterations to existing dwelling house<br />
construction <strong>of</strong> bridge and landscaping Abbott Tout December 13, 2006 December 13, 2006<br />
2006/<strong>2007</strong><br />
Costs $<br />
Appeal upheld in<br />
relation to amended<br />
proposal Refused Not to <strong>Council</strong> -18<br />
Judgement reserved by<br />
Pain J N/A N/A 149531<br />
approved by <strong>Council</strong><br />
pursuant to 82A -<br />
Appeal discontinued Refused Not to <strong>Council</strong> -336<br />
appeal upheld in<br />
relation to amended<br />
proposal Refusal Refused 64<strong>27</strong><br />
Appeal proceeded only<br />
in relation to conditions,<br />
majority <strong>of</strong> conditions<br />
upheld 376<br />
6 September 12, 2006 10842/2006<br />
25 Gwydir Ave<br />
Cecelia Francesca PNorth Turramurra Hones Lawyers DA0342/06<br />
Deemed refusal <strong>of</strong> additions and<br />
alterations to an existing dwellng and inground<br />
pool Abbott Tout December 14, 2006 December 14,2006<br />
Upheld - consent<br />
granted Refused Not to <strong>Council</strong> 386<br />
6 Total Alterations & Additions 156,366<br />
Dual Occupancy<br />
1 November 5, 2004 11366/2004 Mark Shaynd<br />
86 Kitchener Street<br />
St Ives Hones Lawyers DA0688/04 Deemed Refusal - Dual Occupancy Abbott Tout April 28, 2005<br />
Amended proposal<br />
approved subject to<br />
conditions Refused Not to <strong>Council</strong> -399<br />
4 Munderah St,<br />
2 July 6,2005 10721-10729 BCE Investments (AWahroonga<br />
3 September 6, 2005<br />
11029 &<br />
11030/2005<br />
Ray Fitz-Gibbon<br />
Architects Pty Ltd<br />
406 Mona Vale<br />
Road St Ives<br />
Hones Lawyers<br />
Staunton<br />
Beattie<br />
DA0532/02<br />
A<br />
DA0355/05<br />
2 Luton Place St<br />
4 December 20, 2005 11560/05 Complete ConsultanIves Steven Klinger DA1021/05<br />
5 Subdivision & 4 Dual Occupancy<br />
appeals<br />
Deacons<br />
November 23 & 24 2005,<br />
9 March, 2006,24 & 25<br />
March 2006 April 7, 2006<br />
Deemed Refusal <strong>of</strong> Subdivision and<br />
additions and alteration to existing<br />
residence & Deemed refusal <strong>of</strong> Dual<br />
occupancy Phillips Fox 7, 8, 9 December 2005<br />
Deemed refusal <strong>of</strong> attached Dual<br />
Occupancy<br />
Wilshire Webb<br />
9 December 2005; 3<br />
January 2005<br />
March 31, 2006<br />
changed to 14 March<br />
2006 May 26,2006<br />
Consent orders in<br />
relation to ammended<br />
proposal Refused Not to <strong>Council</strong> 2401<br />
Amended plans<br />
directed to be prepared.<br />
Amended proposal<br />
upheld. Refused Not to <strong>Council</strong> 3555<br />
Amended proposal<br />
approved Refused Not to <strong>Council</strong> 1925<br />
5 June 5, 2006 10475/2006 Gabriel Pedruco<br />
6 August 18, 2006 10726/2006 Architrade Pty Ltd<br />
69 Junction Rd<br />
Wahroonga Hones Lawyers<br />
Staunton<br />
DA0736/05<br />
67 Mona Vale Beattie<br />
Road Pymble Solicitors DA0707/06<br />
Wayne Chafey,<br />
Wordsworth<br />
Lawyers<br />
Refusal <strong>of</strong> proposed demolution <strong>of</strong><br />
existing tennis court and construction <strong>of</strong><br />
a detached dual occupancy Wilshire Webb Discontinued 12959<br />
Deemed refusal <strong>of</strong> two-storey attached<br />
dual occupancy Wilshire Webb 2675<br />
Deemed refusal <strong>of</strong> demolition <strong>of</strong> a local<br />
heritage item (dwelling) and<br />
construction <strong>of</strong> a detached dual Wilshire Webb November 21, 2006 1898<br />
7 August 23, 2006 10743 &10742<br />
5 & 3 Margaret<br />
Regent Street ConstStreet Roseville<br />
DA0560/06<br />
7 TotalDual Occupancy 25,014<br />
7377<strong>27</strong>