18.12.2012 Views

INTERNATIONAL OLYMPIC ACADEMY 7th JOINT - IOA

INTERNATIONAL OLYMPIC ACADEMY 7th JOINT - IOA

INTERNATIONAL OLYMPIC ACADEMY 7th JOINT - IOA

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

APPENDIX<br />

Table 1: Three Different Positions of Globalization Debate<br />

Issues Hyperglobalists Transformationalist Skeptics<br />

On<br />

globalization<br />

Chronology/<br />

periodization<br />

of trend<br />

Conceptions<br />

Actor(s)<br />

On state and<br />

governance<br />

Geography<br />

Globalization<br />

forces<br />

Thoroughly globalized<br />

Recent development:<br />

1960s~ – discontinuity,<br />

enormous<br />

intensification<br />

Americanization<br />

Westernization<br />

Universalization<br />

Liberalization<br />

Deteritorialization<br />

Multilateral institutions<br />

– IMF, WTO, OECD;<br />

trans-border firms<br />

Diminishing/<br />

dissolution/ retreat →<br />

removing governmental<br />

restrictions/<br />

effectiveness; erosion of<br />

autonomy<br />

Transnational relations<br />

– trans-border exchange<br />

Market forces; Liberal<br />

economy, liberal<br />

democracy;<br />

communication<br />

technology<br />

Moderate assessment<br />

– need to consider<br />

other social forces<br />

Unevenness –<br />

carefully measured,<br />

qualified<br />

Continuity +<br />

discontinuity –<br />

historically<br />

unprecedented<br />

powerful but<br />

uncertain<br />

transformative force<br />

Supraterritorility<br />

Relative<br />

deteritorialization<br />

Regionalization/<br />

localization<br />

Global governance<br />

substate/ suprastate<br />

agencies; NGOs,<br />

activists, individuals<br />

Reconstituted/<br />

restructured in forms,<br />

functions, authority;<br />

Multilayered<br />

governance →<br />

redefined<br />

‘sovereignty’<br />

Reconfiguration/<br />

restructuring of space<br />

and time in our lives<br />

Multidimensional<br />

unprecedented<br />

dynamics: global<br />

economic, military,<br />

technological,<br />

ecological, migratory,<br />

political, cultural<br />

flows<br />

- 350 -<br />

Myth/ overexaggeration/<br />

rhetoric<br />

Nothing new: mid-<br />

19th c~ – continuity<br />

Internationalization<br />

Regionalization<br />

Sovereign states,<br />

regional bodies – EU,<br />

NAFTA,<br />

MERCOSUR;<br />

international<br />

organizations<br />

Substantial capacity<br />

and enduring power in<br />

regulation: on<br />

territoriality,<br />

economy, finance,<br />

nationality, military<br />

forces, legitimacy<br />

International relations<br />

– cross-border<br />

exchanges<br />

Economic<br />

interdependencies

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!