28.11.2017 Views

Enayam Port

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Tamil Research Institute<br />

RAPID TECHNO-ECONOMIC FEASIBILITY REPORT FOR<br />

DEVELOPMENT OF COLACHEL PORT AT TAMILNADU<br />

FINAL REPORT<br />

Estimated adverse impacts on each alternative<br />

5.3.3.2. Sensitivity analysis<br />

Table 7: Estimated adverse impacts on each alternative<br />

With these values, we proceed to achieve a global impact magnitude value for each of the alternatives. That<br />

alternative scoring a lesser gross-magnitude impact value would be the better in terms of environmental and<br />

social feasibility.<br />

To obtain that final impact value for each of the alternatives, based on different weightings of the estimated<br />

impacts values, we considered three different scenarios in order to evaluate the performance of the alternatives in<br />

each of them. These are the following:<br />

• Environmental and social factors weight the same. 50%-50%<br />

• All the environmental and social sub-factors weigh the same, i.e. all the adverse impacts weight the same.<br />

• A different weight is given to factors and sub-factors, i.e. to the adverse impacts, based on an expert<br />

judgement.<br />

To carry out this sensitivity analysis, first we proceed to normalize (homogenization) the impact values, converting<br />

them into a 0-100 range, the highest value corresponding to the negative impact of greater magnitude and<br />

therefore the lower valuation of the alternative. The results of the homogeneous evaluation are showed in the<br />

following table:<br />

52<br />

www.tamilri.com

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!