With-Love-to-Muhammad

Statements of Prophet Muhammad sa 105
aن aر aن aحو a خa aاحد aال aدس ان
حدثaنaازریaنaح aبنaدaاانaالaادa ٰ
انaاانaبنaۃaاختطaۃaبعaوaتنaوaاۃa
نaعaہaاaاہaلاa۔ 92
He used to make false reports. Ahmad said, “He has
made mistakes in about 20 narrations from Zuhrī.”
Yahyā bin Sa‘īd said, “I bear witness that Sufyān bin
‘Uyainah became mentally challenged in 197 Hijri.
So, whoever took a narration from him after that, it is
useless.” 93
About Zuhrī, it is written, aاادر“‏ a aدس ‏”‏ان (He used to make
false reports sometimes) 94 . Hence, in the same manner, it
appears that the narrators gave their personal opinion of the
word Al-‘Āqib when they said, “after whom there will be no
prophet.”
Secondly, it is important to note that the Holy Prophet
Muhammad sa was an Arab and his companions were also Arab.
What was the need for him to translate the word Al-‘Āqib? The
very fact that the word was explained in so many words shows
that it was done by a narrator perhaps in discussion with a non-
Arab. This is exactly what Hazrat Mullā ‘Alī Qārī rh has indicated
but Farhan Khan didn’t bother to present the complete
quotation in his own book! What marvellous dishonesty!!! Here
is the actual statement:
92
۳۹۷ زانaالاتدال۔aجد‎۱a۔aحۃa
93
Mīzānul A‘etadāl, Volume 1, Page 398
94
Mīzānul A‘etadāl, Volume 2, Page 146