With-Love-to-Muhammad

Opinion of the Sahāba ra , Ā’immah, and Mujaddidīn rh 213
Moving further into this discussion, let us now see what some
of the ā’immah have said in commentary of the statement of
Hazrat Ayesha ra above.
8. Hazrat Shaikh Al-Imām Hazrat Ibn Qutaiba rh writes in
Tāwīl Mukhtalif Al-Ahādīth, Page 236:
This statement of hers does not contradict the statement of the
Holy Prophet (peace and blessings of Allāh be on him), “Lā
nabiyya ba’adī” [There is no prophet after me] because he
meant, “There would be no prophet after me, who abrogates
what I came with [or who opposes my law].”
9. Hazrat Imam Muhammad Tāhir rh writes in Takmilah
Majma‘ul-Bihār, Page 85:
This [statement of Hazrat Ayesha ra ] had reference to the advent
of ‘Īsā as . It is also not in contradiction with the hadīth, “There
is no prophet after me,” for he intended [to say], “There would
be no prophet [after him] who abrogates his law.”
To bring authenticity to our quotations and to prove we have
not taken them out of context, we have chosen to present the
actual scans of the quotations of the following mujaddidīn:
i. Hazrat Shaikh Ahmad Sirhindī Mujaddid Alaf Thānī rh ,
mujaddid of the 11 th century
ii. Hazrat Shāh Waliullāh Muhaddas Dehlawi rh , mujaddid of
the 12 th century.
The following three pages are scans from the original Persian
book of Hazrat Shaikh Ahmad Sirhindī rh , Maktūbāt Imām