26.05.2014 Views

With-Love-to-Muhammad

With-Love-to-Muhammad

With-Love-to-Muhammad

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

196 <strong>With</strong> <strong>Love</strong> <strong>to</strong> <strong>Muhammad</strong> sa the Khātam-un-Nabiyyīn<br />

reflection of the same <strong>Muhammad</strong> sa and bears his<br />

name. But Jesus as cannot come without breaking the<br />

Seal inasmuch as his is a separate and distinct<br />

prophethood. 210<br />

One can see the great care and veneration the Promised<br />

Messiah as had for the Seal of prophethood borne by the Holy<br />

Prophet <strong>Muhammad</strong> sa . By bringing back Hazrat ‘Īsā as , Farhan<br />

Khan is committing a serious offense against this Seal and he is<br />

disrespecting it even though he casually points the finger at<br />

others.<br />

Second, the Holy Prophet <strong>Muhammad</strong> sa did not say that<br />

no one can be given prophethood after him. He simply said, “Lā<br />

nabiyya ba‘adī” (There is no prophet after me), and <strong>to</strong> manipulate<br />

this <strong>to</strong> mean that prophethood cannot be given <strong>to</strong> anyone after<br />

the Holy Prophet sa is a far-fetched interpretation. The word<br />

given has been inserted by Farhan Khan himself and he cannot<br />

prove its existence in any hadīth.<br />

Third, in support of his argument, Farhan Khan gives an<br />

example by writing, “... a mother has three children: Ahmad,<br />

Yahya, and Fatimah, aged ten, seven, and four, respectively. If<br />

she was asked who her last child is, she would reply Fatimah,<br />

because Fatimah was the last <strong>to</strong> be born in the family.” 211<br />

This is an invalid comparison. Physical birth is<br />

something that, by definition, can only occur once in a unique<br />

sequential order which cannot change, but the issue we are<br />

discussing is the appearance of a prophet for the guidance of<br />

humankind. This, according <strong>to</strong> Farhan Khan’s sect of Muslims,<br />

can occur more than once, particularly in the case of Jesus as .<br />

210<br />

A Misconception Removed, Page 7<br />

211<br />

Khan, <strong>With</strong> <strong>Love</strong>, Page 25

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!