With-Love-to-Muhammad

ؕ
ّ
260 With Love to Muhammad sa the Khātam-un-Nabiyyīn
Tafsīr Ibn ‘Abbās ra is one of the unreliable
commentaries because it is narrated by great liars.
Imām Jalāl-ud-Dīn Suyūtī rh says:
aُ
‏ْر
a َ
‏َّاسً‏
aب َ
‏ْنِ‏
ُ َ ْ و اaاِ‏ َ
aا‏َّتaِ‎ا ْ
‏ْل
اa ِ َ والُ‏ ‏َد
ُ ا َ َّتاa َ
ذِ‏ ہِ‏
ٰ
َ جا‏ِ‏ اa َ ُ َ َ وات aر ُ َ ْ ر َ aو ‏َّۃً‏ ِ
‏ْر
aَاب
These lengthy commentaries which are attributed to
Ibn ‘Abbas ra by the commentators are unwanted and
their narrators are unreliable.
As a result, it is not only proven that Farhan Khan relied upon a
very weak hadīth in support of his points, but he also brought a
completely unauthentic commentary in support of them! Farhan
Khan should bear in mind that:
256
يُرِيْدُ‏ وْنَ‏ لِيُطْ‏ فُِٔوْا نُوْرَ‏ اهللّ‏ ٰ ِ ابِ‏ ‏َفْوَاهِهِمْ‏ وَاهللّ‏ ٰ ُ مُتمِ‏ ُّ
الْكٰفِرُ‏ وْ‏ نَ‏ ۝
وَلَوْ‏ كَرِ‏ ‏َه نُوْرِ‏ ‏ٖه
They desire to extinguish the light of Allāh with the
breath of their mouths, but Allāh will perfect His light,
even if the disbelievers hate it. 257
No matter how much people try to extinguish the light which
has been kindled by Allāh, they will never succeed! It has been
declared by Allāh:
۝
كَتَبَ‏ اهللّ‏ ٰ ُ لاَ‏ ‏َغْلِبنَ‏ َّ اَانَ‏ وَرُ‏ سُ‏ لىِ‏ ْ
اِنَّ‏ اهللّ‏ ٰ َ قَوِىٌّ‏ عَزِيْزٌ‏
256
Tafsir Itqaan, Volume 2, page 188
257
Sūrah As-Saff, 61:9