26.05.2014 Views

With-Love-to-Muhammad

With-Love-to-Muhammad

With-Love-to-Muhammad

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Continuation of Prophethood according <strong>to</strong> Ahādīth 297<br />

ااaاaحدثaانa aہaامaخارج ٰ<br />

For we used <strong>to</strong> discuss that ‘Īsā as shall appear<br />

Hazrat Mughīrah ra specifically chose the word ‏”خارج“‏ (will<br />

appear) instead of ‏”‏ازلaنaااء“‏ (will descend from heaven) and<br />

this clearly shows that he did not believe that the Israelite Īsā as<br />

ascended bodily in<strong>to</strong> the heavens, and therefore, must<br />

inevitably have died. Now it is left up <strong>to</strong> Farhan Khan <strong>to</strong> wait<br />

for a deceased Israelite prophet or accept the prophet who was<br />

sent by Allāh, the Exalted, from among the followers of the<br />

Holy Prophet <strong>Muhammad</strong> sa . One thing is certain – and Farhan<br />

Khan will also agree <strong>to</strong> this – that once a person dies, he never<br />

returns <strong>to</strong> this world. So, good luck!<br />

Second, Farhan Khan accuses the Ahmadī Muslims when<br />

he says, “…what they (Ahmadī Muslims) conveniently fail <strong>to</strong><br />

report is the Hadīth immediately below the Hadīth of A’isha ra in<br />

Al-Dūr Al-Manthūr, which explains the narration of Aisha ra .” 293<br />

Not only is this untrue as shown in the chapter entitled The<br />

Death of Hazrat ‘Īsā as , it is completely illogical. Essentially,<br />

Farhan Khan is saying that a statement of Hazrat Ayesha ra is<br />

explained by a statement of Hazrat Mughīrah ra when, in fact,<br />

both their statements are completely independent of each other.<br />

Third, the absoluteness of Farhan Khan’s beliefs is utterly<br />

shattered when he says, “…Al-Mughīrah preferred seal of the<br />

Prophets, because no prophets after him may create the impression<br />

that ‘Esā bin Marīam will not return.” 294 In his entire book,<br />

Farhan Khan has been emphasizing that there can be no more<br />

prophets whatsoever after the Holy Prophet <strong>Muhammad</strong> sa but<br />

293<br />

Khan, <strong>With</strong> <strong>Love</strong>, Page 9<br />

294<br />

Ibid., Page 10

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!