With-Love-to-Muhammad

Relationship of Khātam-un-Nabiyyīn to Lā Nabiyya Ba‘adī 39
On another note, since Farhan Khan is keen on finding
weaknesses in the narrations of the ahādīth presented by
Ahmadī Muslims, he should bear in mind that the above hadīth
that he cites in his book three times and emphasizes in his
YouTube videos has similarly been criticized as weak (dha‘īf) by
his own reputed scholars! It is quoted again as follows:
وaاخرجaابنaردو ہaنaثوبانaرaااللهaہaال:‏ الa
رولaااللهaaااللهaہaوaمaإہaونaaاُ‎تa
ذابونaثثونaمaزمaأہaبa،وaااaخاتمaابنaلاa
بaبدی۔a
Hazrat Thaubān ra narrates that the Holy Prophet sa
said: “Indeed, there will arise in my ummah thirty
arch-liars, each of whom will claim to be a prophet,
and I am the Khātam-un-Nabiyyīn (Seal of prophets),
there is no prophet after me (without my seal)”.
All the varying narrations of the above hadīth are from weak
narrators. For instance, in Jāmi‘ Tirmidhī, it is narrated by Abū
Qalābah and Thaubān, both of whom are weak narrators. About
Abū Qalābah, it is written, سaابوaبۃaنaاءaاتابنaوaوaدa‏“‏
person. (Abū Qalābah was not a wise ‏”ااس aدود aابہ a
Instead, among the people, he was famous for ignorance) 19 . It is
also stated, aحم“‏ aم aن aو aحم aن aدس ‏”اہ (He used to
narrate from those whom he met and from those whom he did
not meet) 20 . About Thaubān, Azdī states, ‏”‏تونaہ“‏ (There is
19
Tehzīb At-Tehzīb, Volume 5, Page 226
20
Mīzānul A‘itadāl, Volume 2, Page 39