26.05.2014 Views

With-Love-to-Muhammad

With-Love-to-Muhammad

With-Love-to-Muhammad

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

ْ<br />

َ<br />

290 <strong>With</strong> <strong>Love</strong> <strong>to</strong> <strong>Muhammad</strong> sa the Khātam-un-Nabiyyīn<br />

It is simply ridiculous <strong>to</strong> see Farhan Khan’s extraordinary bias<br />

against the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamā‘at. The above ahādīth are<br />

recorded right next <strong>to</strong> the hadīth under discussion, but Farhan<br />

Khan deliberately chose <strong>to</strong> not mention them. Instead, he went<br />

out of his way <strong>to</strong> select a narration where the sequence of his<br />

liking was found and he used that <strong>to</strong> prove his points. However,<br />

the truth is that the Holy Prophet <strong>Muhammad</strong> sa did not speak of<br />

Masjid-an-Nabwī as the last of the mosques in any of these<br />

narrations. He merely pointed out the importance of these three<br />

mosques, that is, Masjid-an-Nabwī, Masjid Al-Harām, and Bait-ul-<br />

Muqaddas, and he has spoken of them in different sequences.<br />

There are times when he mentioned Masjid-an-Nabwī first, and<br />

there are times when he mentioned it second, and there are<br />

times when he mentioned it last. What does this tell us? This<br />

tells us that he had no intention <strong>to</strong> speak of Masjid-an-Nabwī as the<br />

last mosque!<br />

Fourth, Farhan Khan’s argument is inconsistent with the<br />

context of the hadīth under discussion. The Holy Prophet<br />

<strong>Muhammad</strong> sa himself clarified that he is only speaking of<br />

mosques in respect of their greatness or status as indicated by<br />

the words:<br />

‏ْہِ‏ aو َ َّ َ َ مa<br />

َ َa aااللهُ‏ َّ َa aااللهِ‏ ولِ‏ ُ َ َa a ِ ۃ َ َ<br />

َ ْ ُ<br />

ْاa ن a<br />

َْ لُ‏<br />

ِa وَ‏ اہ a ِ ا َa ِ ۃً‏ َ a َ<br />

ِ ن aأ‏ْفِ‏<br />

أ اa َ َ امَ‏<br />

ْ د<br />

اْ جِ‏<br />

‏ْحَ‏<br />

ر<br />

ْ جِ‏ دِ‏ aر<br />

إلاa َ اجِ‏ دِ‏<br />

Prayer in the mosque of Allāh’s Messenger sa is more<br />

excellent than a thousand prayers in other mosques,<br />

except the Masjid Al-Harām<br />

Hence, he was speaking in terms of status and this clearly<br />

demonstrates that, later in the same narration, he used the word

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!