icegov2012 proceedings

3 indicators are similar but not the same. In this case, the ranking
process may use only 3 indicators, especially if the principle of
parsimony is applied.
Table 4a. Head (first 6 lines) of data frame obtained by
applying the ProdOrdr function to place ranks of infant
health measurement for 5 indicators via the R commands [4]
CaseIDs AA SS ORDIT Salient
1 13.08 7.48 8692.086 46.5
2 13.08 7.48 8692.086 46.5
3 12.15 19.63 8785.223 52
4 5.61 30.84 9439.327 71.5
5 3.74 28.97 9626.301 80
6 21.5 6.54 7850.083 28.5
Table 4b. Head (first 6 lines) of data frame obtained by
applying the ProdOrdr function to place ranks of infant
health measurement for 3 indicators via the R commands [8]
CaseIDs AA SS ORDIT Salient
salient3
1 13.08 57.94 8692.667 79
2 19.63 38.32 8037.477 58
3 14.02 53.27 8598.62 76
4 24.3 35.51 7570.469 51
5 20.56 37.38 7944.471 57
6 46.73 7.48 5327.14 22
0 20 40 60 80 100
45
0 20 40 60 80 100
salient5
Figure 4. Scatter Plot of salient with 5 indicators and 3
indicators as generated by R [8]
Precedence plot of districts by product-order is shown in Figure
5a and 5b. The labels on plotted points in Figure 5 are district
numbers in the data file. These lines must be retrieved to
determine identities of the respective districts. Table 6a shows the
five most severe districts based on 5 indicators and Figure 6a
shows the map of these districts. Location of the 3 districts (90,
64
61
15
93
231
87, 81) is in West Java, while one district (47) is in Central Java
and district 58 is at the border of Central Java and East Java.
Table 6b shows the 5 least severe districts based on 5 indicators
and Figure 6b shows the map of these districts. Location of the 5
least severe districts (city type) is in the central of its main district
and almost cannot be seen from the map on Figure 6b; district 73
is in the middle of district 51 in Central Java; district 31 is in the
middle of district 5; district 106 is a small area in the west area of
the island; district 35 is in the middle of district 16; district 36 is
in the middle of district 19. The three districts (31, 35, 36) are in
East Java area.
AA as %DD
AA as %DD
0 20 40 60
0 20 40 60 80
90
87
47
58 84
0 20 40 60 80
4758
72
44
83
45
90
61
79
81
9
SS as %DD (Deleted Domain)
(a)
77 30
34
31
43 73
0 20 40 60 80
SS as %DD (Deleted Domain)
35 36 75
106
95 77 30
101 34 7536
106 96
103 78
43 31
7338
(b)
Figure 5. Precedence plot (based on place ranks) of districts
labeled with district numbers for 5 indicators (a) and 3
indicators (b), from R commands [8]
6