22.06.2013 Views

Grammatically Correct: The writer's essential guide to punctuation ...

Grammatically Correct: The writer's essential guide to punctuation ...

Grammatically Correct: The writer's essential guide to punctuation ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

STYLE<br />

Many modern readers would not agree. An example of the turn<br />

in thinking can be found in the 1976 update of Dr. Benjamin Spack's<br />

best-selling Baby and Child Care, where he states in a foreword:<br />

<strong>The</strong> main reason for this [revision] is <strong>to</strong> eliminate the<br />

sexist biases of the sort that help <strong>to</strong> create and perpetuate<br />

discrimination against girls and women. Earlier ed'itions<br />

referred <strong>to</strong> the child of indeterminate sex as "he". Though<br />

this in one sense is only a literary tradition, it, like many<br />

other traditions, implies that the masculine sex has some<br />

kind of priority.<br />

Feeling that he is inappropriate when applied <strong>to</strong> both sexes is one<br />

thing; finding a graceful alternative is another. Strunk and White<br />

raised some valid objections when they went on <strong>to</strong> say:<br />

Substituting he or she in its place. . . . often doesn't<br />

work, if only because repetition makes it sound boring or<br />

silly. . . . <strong>The</strong> juror recently raised about "he" would be<br />

more impressive if there were a handy substitute for the<br />

word. Urifortunately, there isn't-or at least, no one has<br />

come up with one yet. If you think "she" is a handy substitute<br />

for "he, " try it and see what happens. Alternatively,<br />

put all controversial nouns in the plural and avoid the<br />

choice of sex al<strong>to</strong>gether, and you may find your prose<br />

sounding general and diffuse as a result.<br />

Clearly, the "recently raised" furor hasn't gone away, but neither<br />

has anyone come up yet with a handy substitute. (For some reason,<br />

"shim" hasn't caught on.) <strong>The</strong> challenge, therefore, is <strong>to</strong> find less<br />

handy substitutes. <strong>The</strong>se sometimes take a bit of ingenuity but, if<br />

successful, allow you <strong>to</strong> work around the problem without your readers<br />

even noticing. <strong>The</strong> pros and cons of various strategies are<br />

discussed below.<br />

USING HE/SHE, SIRE, OR THEY<br />

<strong>The</strong> solutions that are the easiest <strong>to</strong> apply are also the least likely<br />

<strong>to</strong> please: putting down he/she or s/he, or using they as a singular<br />

pronoun. <strong>The</strong> first two are jarring; the third ungrammatical. All three<br />

seem like cop-outs (as if you couldn't take the trouble <strong>to</strong> come up<br />

297

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!