14.02.2021 Views

Tahafut_al-Tahafut-transl-Engl-van-den-Bergh

a book on philosophy

a book on philosophy

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

I say:

which has a reasonable sense, to the power of the

Omnipotent, also has an intelligible meaning.’

That non-existence of this kind occurs is true, and the philosophers

admit it, because it proceeds from the agent according to a second

intention and accidentally; but it does not follow from its proceeding or

from its having a reasonable meaning that it happens essentially or

primarily, and the difference between the philosophers and those who

deny the occurrence of non-existence is that the philosophers do not

absolutely deny the occurrence of non-existence, but only its occurring

primarily and essentially through the agent. For the act of the agent does

not attach itself necessarily, primarily, and essentially to non-existence,

and according to the philosophers non-existence happens only

subsequently to the agent’s act in reality. The difficulties ensue only for

those who affirm that the world can be annihilated in an absolute

annihilation.

Ghazali says:

I say:

Perhaps the philosophers will answer: This difficulty is

only acute for those who allow the non-existence of a thing

after its existence, for those may be asked what the reality is

that occurs. But according to us philosophers the existing

thing does not become non-existent, for we understand by

the fact that the accidents become non-existent the

occurrence of their opposites, which are existing realities,

and not the occurrence of mere non-existence which is

nothing at all, and how could what is nothing at all be said to

occur? For if hair becomes white, it is simply whiteness that

occurs, for whiteness is something real; but one cannot say

that what occurs is the privation of blackness.’

This answer on behalf of the philosophers is mistaken, for the

philosophers do not deny that non-existence occurs and happens through

the agent, not, however, according to a primary intention as would be the

consequence for one who assumes that a thing can change into pure

133

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!