14.02.2021 Views

Tahafut_al-Tahafut-transl-Engl-van-den-Bergh

a book on philosophy

a book on philosophy

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

but the intellectual faculty becomes strong in most cases

only after this age. ‘ And the loss of insight in the intelligibles,

through illness in the body and through dotage in old age,

does not argue against this, for as long as it is proved that at

certain times the intellect is strong notwithstanding the

weakness of the body, it is clear that it exists by itself, and its

decline at the time of the declining of the body does not

imply that it exists through the body, for from a negative

consequent alternating with a positive consequent there is

no inference. For we say that, if the intellectual faculty exists

through the body, then the weakness of the body will

weaken it at all times, but the consequent is false and

therefore the antecedent is false; but, when we say the

consequent is true, sometimes it does not follow that the

antecedent is true. Further, the cause of this is that the soul

has an activity through itself, when nothing hinders it and it is

not preoccupied with something. For the soul has two kinds

of action, one in relation to the body, namely to govern and

rule it, and one in relation to its principles and essence, and

this is to perceive the intelligibles, and these two kinds of

action hinder each other and are opposed to each other, and

when it is occupied with the one action, it turns away from

the other and it cannot combine both. And its occupations

through the body are sense-perception and imagination and

the passions, anger, fear, grief, and pain, but when it sets

out to think the intelligible it neglects all these other things.

Yes, sense-perception by itself sometimes hinders the

apprehension and contemplation of the intellect without the

occurrence of any damage to the organ of the intellect or to

the intellect itself, and the reason for this is that the soul is

prevented from one action through being occupied with

another, and therefore during pain, disease, and fear-for this

also is a disease of the brain-intellectual speculation leaves

off. And why should it be impossible that through this

difference in these two kinds of action in the soul they should

hinder each other, since even two acts of the same kind may

impede each other, for fear is stunned by pain and desire by

458

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!