14.02.2021 Views

Tahafut_al-Tahafut-transl-Engl-van-den-Bergh

a book on philosophy

a book on philosophy

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

I say:

says that the lamp makes the light and the man makes the

shadow uses the term vaguely, giving it a sense much wider

than its definition, and uses it metaphorically, relying on the

fact that there is an analogy between the object originally

meant by it and the object to which it is transferred, i.e. the

agent is in a general sense a cause, the lamp is the cause of

the light, and the sun is the cause of luminosity; but the

agent is not called a creative agent from the sole fact that it

is a cause, but by its being a cause in a special way, namely

that it causes through will and through choice. If, therefore,

one said that neither a wall, nor a stone, nor anything

inanimate is an agent, and that only animals have actions,

this could not be denied and his statement would not be

called false. But according to the philosophers a stone has

an action, namely falling and heaviness and a centripetal

tendency, just as fire has an action, namely heating, and a

wall has an action, namely a centripetal tendency and the

throwing of a shadow, and, according to them each of these

actions proceeds from it as its agent; which is absurd.’

There are in brief two points here, the first of which is that only those

who act from deliberation and choice are regarded as acting causes, and

the action of a natural agent producing something else is not counted

among acting causes, while the second point is that the philosophers

regard the procession of the world from God as the necessary connexion

obtaining between shadow and the person, and luminosity and the sun,

and the downward rolling in relation to the stone, but that this cannot be

called an action because the action can be separated from the agent.

I say:

All this is false. For the philosophers believe that there are four causes:

agent, matter, form, and end. The agent is what causes some other thing

to pass from potency to actuality and from nonexistence to existence; this

actualization occurs sometimes from deliberation and choice, sometimes

by nature, and the philosophers do not call a person who throws a shadow

an agent, except metaphorically, because the shadow cannot be

139

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!