06.04.2013 Views

Johnson 2004 - CDLI - UCLA

Johnson 2004 - CDLI - UCLA

Johnson 2004 - CDLI - UCLA

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Italian and Greek, see Lyons 1999, 22-25 with references). Bare nouns in Sumerian,<br />

therefore, have at least the possibility of being indefinite.<br />

The other piece of, admittedly, indirect evidence in favor of linking the BNBV inal<br />

distributional class with indefiniteness has to do with the location of the so-called<br />

dimensional infixes (a class of directional morphemes that appear in the verbal prefix)<br />

within the Sumerian verb: in purely formal terms, the *bi-√ prefix excludes the entire set<br />

of dimensional infixes. In the system of numbered morphosyntactic slots proposed by<br />

Jagersma/Zólyomi, the dimensional infixes occupy slots [ ] 7 through [ ] 9, whereas the<br />

*bi-√ prefix, segmented into /b/ and /i/ fills slots [ ] 5/6 and [ ] 10. In the slightly different<br />

system in use at the Pennsylvania Sumerian Dictionary, the dimensional infixes fill slots<br />

[ ] 4, [ ] 6, and [ ] 8, while the *bi-√ prefix is split into slots [ ] 3 and [ ] 9. The point that is<br />

recognized by both systems is, as plainly stated by Gragg, “[t]he dimensional infixes, as a<br />

rule, do not occur with bí-, im.mi-, or al-” (Gragg 1973a, 15). But more importantly,<br />

Gragg’s seminal work on the dimensional infixes makes clear that there is no regular<br />

“agreement” between postpositions and dimensional infixes:<br />

In these literary texts there are approximately 700 occurrences of the postposition<br />

- ß è . But the infix - ß i - occurs only 142 times. … of these 142 occurrences of the<br />

infix, only 35 give the infix and the postposition together. While these statistics do<br />

not disprove the view just outlined [that the infixes arise through “agreement” with<br />

co-occurring postpositions], they do make it seem less likely; in fact, given these<br />

statistics one might well hypothesize that the infix and the postposition tend to be<br />

mutually exclusive rather than interdependent” (Gragg 1973a, 16)<br />

83

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!