TQM Model of Elements-Deployment Table Developed from Quality ...

(6) As for the period from the application to recognition, the Deming Prize is one year
and the MBNQA is six months (Remark: However, Deming Prize is that physically
May 31 is the deadline of application presentation and announcement of recipient
and Deming Ceremony are November that it is also six months).
(7) Regarding for these discussion, Mr. Reimann (NIST, Quality Program, Associate
Director) [12] was supplemented as follows;
(a) The MBNQA is more appreciated TQM or the Total Quality concept.
(b) Target Community is covering broader sectors as manufacturing, service,
government, hospital, and school.
(c) The MBNQA is heading for performance orient evaluation, and appreciating
results than Deming Prize evaluation. As for organization or methodology
concerns, it is depending on industries options as non-restrictist and just
request for evidence of their innovation atatus and adaption effectiveness.
(d) The examiner team of the MBNQA selects the examination committee member
among professional people in industrial sector and university every year. And,
those members have not any experiences of guidance relations with potential
applicant organization like Deming Prize. This is reason that a specific
technique is not encouraged like above-mentioned Performance Orientation at
all.
(e) The MBNQA was designed for not emphasizing on qualification evaluation, but
for competitive based evaluation, because a competitive oriented system are
more encouraging to apply by the best model in every industries. The Deming
Prize evaluation is soley depending on JUSE Counsellor's (Note: Academic
society and public professional experts) interpretations for the criteria.
It is understood that the Deming Prize emphasize TQM and use of the statistical
method and the MBNQA emphasize Total Quality with competitive concept.
(B) Nakhai & Neves [13] presented the paper that the Deming Prize, the MBNQA, and
the EQA call under Quality Management Continuum, and compared their award
criteria and application categories, based on their fundamental value creation
concept and their Quality Management concept as follows in 1994.
(1) The Deming Prize is defined "The prize is given to the enterprise to which it is
recognized that the Total Quality Control based on the Statistical Quality Control
was surely executed, and seems to be continued it in the future". Evaluation
characteristics are specified quality assurance activities, quality performance, and
elimination of failure, but not for human resources development, customer
satisfaction, influence to society and business performance evaluation categories. It
is requested to be paying attention on cost, productivity, delivery date, safety, and
environmental consideration, but not in MBNQA and EQA.
99