TQM Model of Elements-Deployment Table Developed from Quality ...

The EQA was further expanded the concept, and introduced the element such as
"Employee satisfaction rate, Influence on the society (corporate citizen, qualify of life,
environment and resource preservation, and social contribution), and Results of the
management".
And the JQA, in addition of MBNQA requirement, requested "Human Resources
Development, and Learning Environment" and "Management Responsibility".
Deming Prize was revised in 1999 and 2002 as “Stakeholder Relationships
(customer, employee, society, traders, stockholder)”, requirement for TQM Management
System (Daily Management, Policy Management), Business Element Management
System (Quality, Cost, Delivery date, and Safety), Management for TQM concept and
Value of TQM were contained with feature and evaluation points in criteria,
additionally.
Business Management is shifting to TQM concept as for focal points of business
excution by expanding and upgrading of TQM requirement, and indicating for direction
of worldwide Quality Standard. When summarizing the above, it could be concluded
Criteria itself is also progressing and advancing with time-transition.
4.3.2 Comparison of Criteria
(1) Outline
Table 4.2 is prepared for "Criteria Comparison table on MBNQA, EQA, JQA, and
Deming Prize" and Table 4.3 is for "Weight Comparison Table of the Criterias items".
Table 4.3 Weight comparison table of Criteria item
Kind of Award Enabler system Result system
MBNQA 6 Categories:550 1 Category: 450
points
points
EQA 5 Categories: 50% 4 Category: 50%
JQA 7 Categories: 550 1 Category: 450
points
points
Deming Prize 16 Categories:
(100%)
(2) Title
The JQA and Deming Prize were independently established by private
organizations though MBNQA was instituted by law in the country, and EQA was
founded by EFQM received the support of EU. The Deming Prize was established by
commemoration of Dr. Deming friendship and contribution that was crowned his name
for appreciation. However, it is not so much powerful to inherit his name in local
destrict as of USA, SQA or LAA. However JQA concerns, it is observed some kinds of
Quality Award establishment program by prefecture base. MBNQA is so famous to
crown on his name of Secretary of Department of Commerce for his contribution, but
EQA and JQA are just follow by country or union of countries.
106