TQM Model of Elements-Deployment Table Developed from Quality ...

It was President TQM Diagnosis in Deming Prize + JQM that was thought
corresponding to this, and this was a feature of Japan. Though self-assessment are
carried by educated self-assessment examiners, this education is given to even
executives in Canada. (Depend on the offer material from Ms. Margaret Strus:
President, the Strus & Associates Inc.). If this is operated well, it could be applicable as
same as Japanese President TQM Diagnosis.
The biggest differnce observed in MBNQA is none of guidance for preparation of
Award application by guidance lecturers, but only Self-Assessment and direct physical
examination, which system are rather simple and easy to the applicant enterprise
without any development own TQM methodology fit-in own product and customer
demand, but just done to study the TQM technique voluntarily agreeing with its
company, and to develop the new management technique for Bench-Marking level
program (for instance, Bench Marking of the Xerox Co.). This concept development was
originated under the scheme of how to improve quality level and international
conpetitiveness of industry that urgent approach has to proceed on the formura (Self
–Assessment and Award Criteria).
It might be above-mentioned point, the MBNQA be "Medical Examination", and
Deming Prize + JQM be a reason said, it is "Physical Fitness Test".
Because both of the quality awards are fiscal year award, application can be done
even how many times. The Solectron Corporation (1991 recipient) that recieved six
years later the second (1997) is assumed the reason of "Correspond to the change in the
age" is this respect in the MBNQA. There is similarly for the Deming Prize that
acquires the application qualification for JQM in addition in five years. Because JQM is
examined from the Deming Prize level by a higher acceptable level, the enterprise that
challenges this should reach the management level of a more advanced high level.
Therefore, the lecturer guidance will enter deep in the enterprise though the lecturer
guidance of Deming Prize + JQM enumerated the results of the academic-industrial
cooperation. The “Question and Answer” will be still repeated though the judge of
Deming Prize + JQM is done by lecturers other than the guidance lecturer.
Andrea [4] said this respect is as follows.
『Moreover, the security of companies by the Baldrige committee does not appear to be
as rigorous as that of the JUSE committee; otherwise, it is unlikely that IBM, which
with-draw its Japanese subsidiary from the race for the Deming Prize precisely because
of the level of disclosure required by JUSE, would twice have been willing to subject
itself to the security of the Baldrige examination.』(Author note: IBM was MBNQA
266