TQM Model of Elements-Deployment Table Developed from Quality ...

qualified judge, sustaining of good business report by TQM implementation,
and following of the procession of the enterprise that continues a considerable
leap.
(2) The given Award is not a source of the authority, but the source of the authority
of the Quality Award is solely depending upon the continuousness of enterprise
effort to improve the enterprise by TQM and the ability of the judge member who
guides the enterprise to create the excellence.』
The above is a valuable paper analyzing difference between self-assessment and
Deming prize examination.
9.2.4 Quality Awards for Future
(A) The overall consideration
When MBNQA, EQA, JQA and Deming Prize is considered by their specific feature,
it is necessary to consider that most of all Solectron Corporation were recognized as
recipient in 1991 and 1997, 2 times for MBNQA in USA and further such muti-time
recipients industries will be challengable more, though character and management of
awards is described since now.
That is, if it is thought that multi time recipient enterprise have continuous
promotion of TQM after first recipient, it is necessary to consider that Deming Prize has
the Recognition of TQM Achievement and muti time recipient enterprises, and then the
JQM be able to acquires the application qualification after 5 years of Deming Prize
recipient. Then, it is a comparison research result that it targets not made of It is
considered about two awards tgat MBNQA to be executed until 15 years of 2002 and to
collect the information investigation comparatively and Deming Prize + JQM, because
EQA is investigatd not enough until now yet, and the JQA has recognized only the
recipient enterprise until 9 year.
(B) Character of award
When comparing the two Quality Awards, the most remarkable identification is
that the MBNQA is enacted by the Law in the country and is managing by
Governmental Institute which potent influences are spreaded into establishment of
State Awad and the City (Local) Award that are useful for the formation of Quality
Culture under the national policy in the USA. However, the Deming Prize was
established under serious recognition of necessary for renovation of Japanese Industry
by a private organization, JUSE. Accordingly, Deming Prize +JQM is to aim at the
improvement of compny constitution and learning of TQM by recognizing "Problem on
the improvement of compny constitution" as an enterprise. Therefore, the spread of a
latter prize doesn't have the spread power of state award establishment like USA.
However, there is a strong point in the point of having obtained the achievment results
263