16.12.2012 Views

Therapies for Children With Autism Spectrum Disorders

Therapies for Children With Autism Spectrum Disorders

Therapies for Children With Autism Spectrum Disorders

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Dietary and Other Medical Interventions<br />

Additional studies in the medical literature addressed the use of dietary interventions<br />

(including special diets) as well as medical therapies <strong>for</strong> sleep and gastrointestinal dysfunction,<br />

hyperbaric oxygen, and other agents.<br />

Content of the literature-dietary interventions. We identified eight studies conducted in the<br />

clinic setting that addressed the use of various oral dietary supplements to treat ASDs in children,<br />

including ages ranging from one to 18 years; interventions included iron, 242 magnesium-vitamin<br />

B6, 243 melatonin, 244 ketogenic diet, 245 and fish oil and evening primrose oil. 246 Two studies<br />

focused on amino acid derivatives, including L-carnosine 247 and N,N dimethylglycine, 248 and one<br />

on a digestive enzyme supplement. 249<br />

Studies measured a wide range of outcomes, with little overlap in instruments utilized among<br />

the studies. Most studies analyzed outcomes after 18 days to 3 months; 242,246-249 one study<br />

assessed outcomes after 6 months, 245 one study after a mean of eight months, 243 and one<br />

examined data at a mean of 1.8 years of followup. 244 Five studies reported adverse<br />

events. 242,245,248-250 Table 17 includes additional study in<strong>for</strong>mation.<br />

Summary of the literature-dietary interventions. Two RCTs explored dietary supplementation<br />

with amino acid derivatives in ASDs. The 8-week RCT of daily L-carnosine supplementation<br />

was conducted at a specialty clinic and included 31 children ages three to twelve years with<br />

ASDs. 247 Significant changes on the CGI at 2 weeks compared with 6 weeks were observed in<br />

the L-carnosine group; significant effects on receptive vocabulary and GARS scores were also<br />

observed be<strong>for</strong>e vs. after treatment in this group. However, no significant changes were observed<br />

between groups in the Gilliam <strong>Autism</strong> Rating Scale measure of ASDs severity, Receptive and<br />

Expressive Picture Vocabulary scores, or parent-rated CGI measure of overall improvement.<br />

Adverse effects in the L-carnosine group included sporadic hyperactivity and were alleviated by<br />

dose reduction.<br />

The 4-week randomized controlled trial of daily N,N-dimethylglycine treatment was<br />

conducted at an academic clinic and included 37 children with ASDs ages three to eleven<br />

years. 248 The dimethylglycine group did not improve more than the placebo group on any<br />

behavioral measure (VABS, ABC-C). There was no significant effect on neurologic examination<br />

of motor skills, muscle tone, or coordination. Adverse effects in the dimethylglycine group were<br />

similar to placebo.<br />

A six month, double blind, crossover RCT of a digestive enzyme supplement (Peptizyde)<br />

which combines the enzymes peptidase, protease 4.5, and papain, included 43 children between<br />

the ages of 3 and 8 years (mean= 69.4 months). 249 Most participants (84 percent) were diagnosed<br />

with autistic disorder. Participants were randomized to either enzyme <strong>for</strong> three months followed,<br />

after a one-week washout period, by placebo (n=21) or placebo <strong>for</strong> three months (one-week<br />

washout period) followed by enzyme (n=22). Sixteen participants (10 in the enzyme/placebo<br />

group and 6 in placebo/enzyme) dropped out of the study <strong>for</strong> reasons including a parentperceived<br />

increase in negative behavior and child refusal to eat food with contents of enzyme<br />

capsules added. In intention to treat analyses, investigators reported significant differences<br />

between enzyme and placebo only on a measure of food selectivity, which was not sustained<br />

over the study period. Investigators noted no serious adverse effects though four children<br />

withdrew from the study because of behavioral deterioration perceived by parents. The authors<br />

also assessed potential effects of alternative therapies, multivitamins, prescription medications,<br />

73

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!