09.12.2012 Views

I__. - International Military Testing Association

I__. - International Military Testing Association

I__. - International Military Testing Association

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

--. ..____ s<br />

platoons. Team Chiefs, coded as dummy control variables, were<br />

used to partial out differences in platoon averages associated<br />

with instructor teams. Other variables in the analysis of field<br />

exercise ratings were leader position and day of MTT. Effects of<br />

these variables were found to be independent of the time trends,<br />

and are not presented here. See Bessemer (In publication) for<br />

further details on the analyses and statistical results.<br />

Results<br />

In baseline AOB classes, the number of movement evaluations,<br />

but not contact evaluations declined for elementary exercises, as, _.<br />

Figures 1 and 2 show. The total elementary evaluations in Figure<br />

3 combine these categories. The baseline change reflects efforts<br />

made to conserve training resources. Contact evaluations were<br />

reduced further in classes with SIMNET AND HMMWV training. In<br />

contrast, for baseline classes in Figure 4, evaluations counted<br />

in advanced exercise showed no trend. These evaluations then<br />

increased in number after the added training began. Thus, SIMNET<br />

and/or HMMW training produced some immediate savings in the<br />

amount of elementary MTT training, which then was replaced by<br />

more advanced training exercises in the later AOB classes.<br />

The effect for field ratings shown in Figure 5 was like that<br />

for advanced evaluations. Average student ratings across classes<br />

gradually increased after the SIMNET and HMMW training was added<br />

to the AOB course, indicating positive transfer to performance in<br />

the student's initial MTT exercise emerged in later classes.<br />

For the graduate quality measure, the best-fitting trends<br />

shown in Figure 6 were not quite significant. Results for the<br />

first SIMNET-trained class are aberrant owing to a change in the<br />

wording of the rating scale in the next class. Omitting the<br />

first class after the baseline, a rank-sum test showed that<br />

graduate quality increased significantly in later classes.<br />

Discussion<br />

The tactical training added to the AOB Course was associated<br />

with three major effects. First, elementary contact exercises<br />

conducted in the MTT decreased in number, and were gradually<br />

replaced by additional advanced exercises involving defense and<br />

offense missions. Second, positive transfer in terms of improved<br />

field exercise performance in the MTT emerged gradually after the<br />

pre-MTT training was expanded by SIMNET training and HMMWV field<br />

exercises. Third, there were indications that the transfer<br />

effect persisted to enhance the judged quality of AOB graduates,<br />

at least for the last classes examined. Careful consideration of<br />

several possible confounding factors led to the conclusion (see<br />

Bessemer, In publication) that SIMNET training, rather than HMMWV<br />

training, was largely responsible for the observed transfer<br />

effects. The gradual emergence of these effects over an extended<br />

time was interpreted as reflecting the accumulation of instructor<br />

experience in using SIMNET to train platoon tactics.<br />

153

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!