10.07.2015 Views

5cjxburmr

5cjxburmr

5cjxburmr

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

practice their religion and, if requested and appropriate, to receive spiritual assistance frompersons, such as chaplains, performing religious functions. 84DoD practice has been for detainees to be provided religious materials of their faith (e.g.,copies of religious texts) as well as time and other accommodations for religious exercise. 858.12 INTELLECTUAL, PHYSICAL, AND RECREATIONAL ACTIVITIESDetainees should be provided with reasonable access to intellectual, physical, andrecreational activities. 86 Such opportunity is increasingly important as detention occurs forlonger periods of time.Access to additional facilities for intellectual, physical, and recreational activities may bemade contingent on compliance with camp rules. 87 Education programs may be offered todiscourage violent extremism. 8884 Consider AP II art. 5(1)(d) (“They shall be allowed to practise their religion and, if requested and appropriate, toreceive spiritual assistance from persons, such as chaplains, performing religious functions;”).85 For example, Admiral Patrick Walsh et al., Department of Defense, Review of Department Compliance withPresident’s Executive Order on Detainee Conditions of Confinement, 25 (2009) (“All detainees [at Guantanamo] areprovided one Koran in the language of their choice, in addition to an Arabic Koran and TafSeer. All detainees areprovided prayer beads, cap, rug, and current prayer schedule. These items are retained by all detainees regardless ofdisciplinary status, unless deliberately used for self-harm or as a weapon. … Guards observe silence during allprayer times. A monthly prayer schedule is published and call to prayer is sounded five times daily in all camps.Prayer is led within each camp and block by a detainee-selected prayer leader. In Camps 2, 3, 5, 6, and Echo groupprayer is typically conducted by detainees from their individual cells. When this occurs, the food tray access doorsof the prayer leaders are lowered to facilitate call to prayer on each block/tier. At times when detainees are engagedin group or communal activities and prayer call sounds, prayer is led by prayer leaders in person. In Camps 4 andIguana, group prayer is conducted in communal areas of the camps. At Camp 7, prayer is conducted individually intheir cells. Guard movement and activity is limited to only those actions required to maintain security. Visualsignals are placed on each block/tier signifying quiet time. Each detainee cell and common area includes an arrowpointing towards Mecca.”).86 For example, DOD DIRECTIVE 2310.01E, DoD Detainee Program, 3b(1) (Aug. 19, 2014) (“Humane treatmentincludes: … (b) Reasonable access to the open air, reasonable educational and intellectual activities, … .”);Chairman’s Commentary to the Copenhagen Process: Principles and Guidelines, 9.3 (“Health and hygiene factorsthat need to be addressed include … ensuring that detainees are permitted to engage in exercise regimes, includingin the open air, … .”). Compare § 9.16 (Intellectual, Physical, and Recreational Activities); § 10.16 (Intellectual,Physical, and Recreational Activities).87 For example, Admiral Patrick Walsh et al., Department of Defense, Review of Department Compliance withPresident’s Executive Order on Detainee Conditions of Confinement, 11 (2009) (“Camp 4 [at Guantanamo], firstoccupied in February 2003, offers communal living, numerous recreation facilities, education and intellectualstimulation programs, and houses detainees considered the most compliant with camp rules. Unlike other camps,Camp 4 offers communal living in open-bay barracks with open access to fresh air in outdoor recreation andcommunal facilities throughout the day. It includes additional access to large recreation areas equipped with abasketball court, volleyball court, and soccer facility, during a specified four-hour period each day. Camp 4 has amedia center equipped with satellite television, bench seating, and a classroom used to teach literacy and art.”).88 For example, Charles A. Allen, Deputy General Counsel, Department of Defense, Alternatives to Prosecution forWar Crimes in the War on Terrorism, 17 TRANSNATIONAL LAW & CONTEMPORARY PROBLEMS 121, 137 (2008)(“For persons in detention in Iraq, MNF-I [Multi-National Force-Iraq] has a reintegration program to try to influencedetainees not to join or rejoin the insurgency, but rather to reintegrate peacefully into society. This effort focuses on502

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!