03.06.2013 Views

JUDAICA - Wisdom In Torah

JUDAICA - Wisdom In Torah

JUDAICA - Wisdom In Torah

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

though Daniel, Psalms, and Proverbs are included in the designation<br />

(18:13–16). It must have been a widespread practice<br />

to refer to the entire Bible in this manner for it is encountered<br />

in the most diverse sources, rabbinic (Tosef., BM 11:23), New<br />

Testament (Matt. 5:17 7:12; 11:13; 22:40; Luke 16:16; John 1:45;<br />

Rom. 3:21), and the Scrolls from the Judean Desert (1QS 1:2–3).<br />

All this can mean only one thing: the Ketuvim were canonized<br />

much later than the Prophets and the tripartite canon<br />

represents three distinct and progressive stages in the process<br />

of canonization. This is not to say, however, that there is any<br />

necessary correlation between the antiquity of the individual<br />

books within a given corpus and the date of the canonization<br />

of the corpus as a whole. Further, a clear distinction has to be<br />

made between the age of the material and the time of its redaction,<br />

the period of its attaining individual canonicity and<br />

the date that it became part of a canonized corpus.<br />

THE CANONIZATION OF THE TORAH (PENTATEUCH). Where<br />

is this differentiation more applicable than in respect of the<br />

<strong>Torah</strong>. A clear distinction must be made between the literature<br />

of the <strong>Torah</strong> and the <strong>Torah</strong> book. Whatever the details of<br />

the incredibly complex history of the pentateuchal material, it<br />

is beyond doubt that much of it is of great antiquity and was<br />

venerated at an early period. The traditional doctrine of Mosaic<br />

authorship of the entire <strong>Torah</strong> has its source in Deuteronomy<br />

31:9–12, 24, more than in any other passage. But the<br />

reference here seems more likely to be to the succeeding song<br />

(Deut. 32), as is indicated by verses 19 and 22. The <strong>Torah</strong> itself<br />

contains no explicit statement ascribing its authorship to<br />

Moses, while Mosaic attribution is restricted to legal and ritual<br />

prescription and is hardly to be found in connection with the<br />

narrative material. Moreover, the term “<strong>Torah</strong>” (which means<br />

“teaching,” as well as “rule” and “law,” has to be examined in<br />

each case in its own context and in no instance can it be unequivocally<br />

understood in its later, comprehensive sense. <strong>In</strong><br />

fact, the phrase “<strong>Torah</strong> of Moses” is not pentateuchal.<br />

An important stage in the history of the pentateuchal<br />

canon is the tale of the chance finding of the “book of the<br />

<strong>Torah</strong>” in 622 B.C.E. as described in II Kings 22–23; II Chronicles<br />

34. It is highly significant that there is no suggestion that<br />

the book is new. <strong>In</strong>deed, given the renewed interest in antiquity,<br />

and the veneration of the past that marked the Near East<br />

of the seventh century B.C.E. and the following two or three<br />

centuries, newness would have been no virtue. The enquiry<br />

of the prophetess Huldah and her reply serve to authenticate<br />

the book and its message. The “<strong>Torah</strong>” was publicly read and<br />

accepted as binding in a national covenant ceremony. The<br />

identity of the book is not given, nor is it termed Mosaic in<br />

direct speech (II Kings 23:25 and II Chron. 34:14 are editorial<br />

remarks). Yet insofar as the ensuing reform of the cult expresses<br />

precisely the leading motifs of *Deuteronomy, it may<br />

be assumed that the ceremony described represents the beginning<br />

of the formation of the Pentateuch, not as literature,<br />

but as a sacred book.<br />

The Law<br />

<strong>Torah</strong><br />

Pentateuch<br />

The Prophets<br />

Nevi’im<br />

The Writings<br />

Ketuvim<br />

Hagiographa<br />

Genesis 50<br />

Exodus 40<br />

Leviticus 27<br />

Numbers 36<br />

Deuteronomy 34<br />

Joshua 24<br />

Judges 21<br />

I Samuel 31<br />

II Samuel 24<br />

I Kings 22<br />

II Kings 25<br />

*Isaiah 66<br />

Jeremiah 52<br />

Ezekiel 48<br />

The Twelve Prophets<br />

Psalms 150<br />

Proverbs 31<br />

Job 42<br />

Song of Songs 8<br />

Ruth 4<br />

Lamentations 5<br />

Ecclesiastes 12<br />

Esther 10<br />

Daniel 12<br />

Ezra 10<br />

Nehemiah 13<br />

I Chronicles 29<br />

II Chronicles 36<br />

Hosea<br />

Joel<br />

Amos<br />

Obadia<br />

Jonah<br />

Micah<br />

Nahum<br />

Habakkuk<br />

Zephaniah<br />

Haggai<br />

Zechariah<br />

Malachi<br />

The first report of the reading of the <strong>Torah</strong> in public assembly<br />

subsequent to Josiah comes from the post-Exilic period,<br />

namely, the ceremony conducted in Jerusalem by Ezra,<br />

approximately 444 B.C.E. (Neh. 8–10). This ceremony cannot<br />

be the occasion of the canonization of the Pentateuch, as has<br />

often been claimed, since the initiative for the public reading<br />

comes from the people and there is no hint that the promulgation<br />

of a new law is involved. The book is called “the book of<br />

the <strong>Torah</strong> of Moses which the Lord commanded Israel” (Neh.<br />

8:1) and the emphasis is on its dissemination and exposition.<br />

It would appear that the <strong>Torah</strong>, or at least some form of it, had<br />

achieved canonical status.<br />

Further evidence that the <strong>Torah</strong> had already been canonized<br />

by this time is provided by the Chronicler and by Samari-<br />

ENCYCLOPAEDIA <strong>JUDAICA</strong>, Second Edition, Volume 3 577<br />

Former Prophets<br />

Later Prophets<br />

Five Scrolls<br />

Megilot<br />

Chapters<br />

bible<br />

14<br />

4<br />

9<br />

1<br />

4<br />

7<br />

3<br />

3<br />

3<br />

2<br />

14<br />

3

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!