10.12.2012 Views

Cambridge Ancient Hi.. - Index of

Cambridge Ancient Hi.. - Index of

Cambridge Ancient Hi.. - Index of

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

holy men 803<br />

A star [he told her] is held to signify the glory <strong>of</strong> an emperor by those who are<br />

expert in interpreting visions; but with you it must not mean this.<br />

Also consulted by Maria, the bishop <strong>of</strong> Anastasiopolis, ‘by God’s inspiration,<br />

gave her the same interpretation’ (V. Theod. Syk. 4, ed. Festugière<br />

(1970) 4, tr. Dawes and Baynes (1997) 88–9). When Theodore, sure enough,<br />

grew up to be both a bishop and a holy man, he functioned in a similar<br />

manner:<br />

if any required medical treatment for certain illnesses or surgery or a purging<br />

draught or hot springs, this God-inspired man would prescribe the best thing for<br />

each, for even in technical matters he had become an experienced doctor . . . and<br />

he would always state clearly which doctor they should employ.<br />

(V. Theod. Syk. 145, ed. Festugière (1970) 114,<br />

Dawes and Baynes (1977) 182; cf. Harvey (1984) 87–93)<br />

Nor did the information flow only in one direction. Viewing the crowds<br />

<strong>of</strong> sufferers around the shrine <strong>of</strong> St Epiphanius at Salamis in the early seventh<br />

century, a ‘philosopher’ informed the bishop that the majority <strong>of</strong> those<br />

present would be cured by a simple change in diet. Responsible for a crowded<br />

healing establishment, the bishop agreed. The philosopher’s remedy worked<br />

wonders (Anastasius Sinaita, Quaestiones 94, PG lxxxix.733a). We know <strong>of</strong><br />

this from the Quaestiones <strong>of</strong> Anastasius <strong>of</strong> Sinai, a monastic writer whose<br />

highly nuanced discussion <strong>of</strong> divine providence, health and miracles contains,<br />

also, the first disturbing hint <strong>of</strong> yet another rival explanatory system –<br />

that <strong>of</strong> Islam. Anastasius knew how Arabs could tell from physiognomic<br />

traits which <strong>of</strong> their warriors would die – presumably as a ‘martyr’ – in battle;<br />

and he had heard <strong>of</strong> the great she-demon who rose from the earth to devour<br />

the camel-sacrifices heaped up around the Ka�ba <strong>of</strong> Mecca (Anastasius<br />

Sinaita, Quaestiones 20, PG lxxxix.521a; Flusin (1991) 404–5).<br />

In normal conditions, the varying layers <strong>of</strong> explanation tended to group<br />

themselves around the holy man, much as the manifold invisible powers<br />

<strong>of</strong> the universe, even the demons, fell into ranks beneath the one God<br />

whom he served. But the possibility <strong>of</strong> conflict was always present, in<br />

which these many layers would fall apart into sharply polarized antithesis.<br />

The most banal <strong>of</strong> these moments <strong>of</strong> conflict concerned the use <strong>of</strong><br />

sorcery. This is hardly surprising. Within the Christian community itself,<br />

members <strong>of</strong> the clergy, like the holy man, were frequently deemed to be<br />

bearers <strong>of</strong> comprehensive knowledge <strong>of</strong> the sacred. Many had knowledge<br />

<strong>of</strong> sorcery. Clergy and lay persons alike were urged to use accustomed<br />

Christian healing substances and, above all, to employ names and formulae<br />

that were to be found only in the canonical Christian scriptures (Greg.<br />

Tur. De Gloria Confessorum 1 and 39). But it was far from certain that such<br />

a seemingly innocent substance as the ‘oil <strong>of</strong> prayer’ would be energized<br />

by Christian prayers or by invocations considered to be tainted by sorcery<br />

<strong>Cambridge</strong> <strong>Hi</strong>stories Online © <strong>Cambridge</strong> University Press, 2008

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!